Member’s Mark Single Barrel Bourbon Review (110 Proof) – A $20 Barton Hidden Gem

Introduction

After reviewing the Member’s Mark Small Batch Bourbon and being impressed with the value it delivered, I was curious to see how its bigger sibling, the Member’s Mark Single Barrel 110 Proof, would hold up.

This release takes things a step further—upping the proof, bottling from individual barrels, and still keeping the price shockingly low at just $19.98 for a 750ml. Like the Small Batch, it’s sourced from Barton 1792 Distillery in Bardstown, Kentucky, the same place responsible for well-loved bourbons like 1792 Small Batch, 1792 Single Barrel, and 1792 Full Proof.

The big question: does this Sam’s Club exclusive manage to capture some of that Barton DNA while offering a true step up from the Small Batch? Let’s break it down.

Bottle Details

• Type: Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey
• ABV (Alcohol by Volume): 55% (110 Proof)
• Mash Bill: Undisclosed (likely Barton’s high-rye recipe)
• Age: NAS (No Age Statement, estimated ~4–6 years)
• Distillation: Barton 1792 Distillery – Bardstown, Kentucky
• Price: $19.98 (Sam’s Club, 750ml)
• Availability: Sam’s Club exclusive

Tasting Notes

Nose

The nose opens with rich caramel, vanilla bean, and a wave of baking spice. There’s a deeper oak influence compared to the Small Batch, with toasted barrel notes, cinnamon, and hints of dark cherry. At 110 proof, it’s bold but not overly hot—showing more maturity and structure than you’d expect from a $20 bottle.

Taste

The palate is full-bodied and carries a punch of flavor. Sweet caramel and brown sugar lead the way, balanced by cinnamon stick, nutmeg, and toasted oak. A layer of dark fruit—plum and black cherry—adds richness before giving way to spice and char. It drinks like something between 1792 Single Barrel and 1792 Full Proof—not quite as intense as Full Proof, but definitely more robust than the Single Barrel.

Finish

Medium to long in length, with lingering oak spice, cocoa powder, and a touch of pepper heat. A sweet caramel and vanilla undertone balances things out, making for a satisfying close that leaves you wanting another sip.

How Much Would I Pay for Member’s Mark Single Barrel 110 Proof?

💸 Max Price I Would Pay: $35 💸

At $19.98, this is one of the best values in bourbon today. It drinks well above its price point, competes with bottles in the $30–40 range, and offers a flavor profile usually reserved for more premium releases.